Hexagram 31.3 — Influence (Third Line)
Xian · Influence in the Thighs — 三爻 · Holding to Following Brings Humiliation
咸卦 · 九三(咸其股,执其随,往吝)
Read from the bottom upward. The highlighted bar marks the third line (三爻), which is the focus of this page.
If You Just Cast This Line
The third line of Influence speaks to a critical threshold: the moment when attraction becomes compulsion, when response becomes reactivity. This line sits at the top of the lower trigram, the place where internal impulse meets external engagement. It warns against being pulled forward by desire alone, without grounding in wisdom or discernment.
The thighs are the muscles of locomotion—they carry us toward what attracts us. But when influence resides only in the thighs, movement becomes automatic, driven by stimulus rather than intention. "Holding to following" means clinging to every impulse, chasing every attraction. The oracle counsels restraint: not all magnetic pulls deserve pursuit. Discrimination protects dignity.
Key Concepts
Original Text & Translation
「咸其股,执其随,往吝。」 — Influence in the thighs; holding to following brings humiliation. Going forward leads to regret.
The image is visceral: the thighs twitch with readiness, eager to move toward the object of attraction. But this is not heart-centered influence or mind-guided connection—it is reflex. The line warns that if you allow every attraction to dictate your direction, you lose agency. You become a follower of impulses rather than an author of choices. The result is embarrassment, wasted energy, and compromised integrity.
Core Meaning
Line three occupies the transitional zone between inner and outer trigrams. In Hexagram 31, Influence, this is the moment when private feeling meets public action. The danger here is that the momentum of attraction—whether romantic, professional, or ideological—overrides judgment. You feel pulled, and you move, without asking whether the pull serves your larger purpose.
The thighs symbolize automatic response: they carry the body wherever the eyes or heart direct it. But influence at this level is shallow. It lacks the depth of heart (line four) or the clarity of mind (line five). The oracle does not say "do not move"—it says "do not move reflexively." Test the attraction. Ask what it serves. If the answer is only "because I want to," that is not yet wisdom. Humiliation comes not from desire itself, but from surrendering choice to desire.
This line also addresses codependency and people-pleasing. "Holding to following" can mean attaching yourself to another's direction, abandoning your own center in order to stay close. The result is loss of self-respect and, eventually, the respect of others. Influence should be mutual and conscious, not compulsive and one-sided.
Symbolism & Imagery
The thighs are powerful but not sovereign. They execute commands from above—from the heart, the mind, the will. When influence resides in the thighs alone, the body moves but the spirit does not lead. This is the image of distraction: scrolling, chasing trends, following crowds, pursuing novelty without purpose. The motion is real, but the direction is borrowed.
In relationships, this line evokes the person who cannot say no, who molds themselves to every partner's preference, who mistakes accommodation for love. In work, it is the professional who jumps at every opportunity without a strategy, who says yes to every request and wonders why they feel scattered. The thighs are strong, but without the spine (the central will), strength becomes servitude.
The oracle's use of "humiliation" (吝, lìn) is instructive. It does not mean catastrophe—it means the small, corrosive shame of realizing you've given your power away. It is the regret of looking back and seeing a trail of half-commitments, each one made because something sparkled in the moment. The remedy is not to stop feeling attraction, but to install a gate between feeling and action.
Action Guidance
Career & Business
- Pause before yes: when an opportunity excites you, write down why. Wait 24 hours. If the reasons still hold and align with your strategy, proceed. If they were only excitement, decline.
- Audit your commitments: list every active project and obligation. Highlight the ones you chose intentionally versus the ones you drifted into. Begin sunsetting the drifts.
- Set selection criteria: define 3–5 non-negotiables for new work (e.g., strategic fit, margin, team quality, timeline). Use them as a filter, not a wish list.
- Practice strategic no: declining with clarity ("This doesn't align with our focus right now, but I appreciate the thought") builds respect and boundaries.
- Resist comparison-driven pivots: if you're tempted to chase a competitor's move or a hot trend, ask whether it serves your unique position or just mimics theirs.
- Distinguish urgency from importance: the thighs respond to urgency. The heart and mind respond to importance. Prioritize the latter.
Love & Relationships
- Notice reflexive accommodation: do you change plans, opinions, or preferences automatically to match your partner's? That is influence in the thighs. Practice stating your authentic preference, even in small things.
- Slow down pursuit: if you feel compelled to text, call, or reach out constantly, pause. Let space exist. Healthy attraction does not require constant motion.
- Check for reciprocity: are you doing all the adapting? All the initiating? If so, you are following, not connecting. Rebalance or reconsider.
- Separate chemistry from compatibility: strong attraction is not the same as aligned values, communication styles, or life goals. Let time reveal the difference.
- Avoid "holding to following": do not abandon your friends, routines, or interests to orbit someone else's life. Maintain your center; let connection be an addition, not a replacement.
- Ask "What am I hoping this will solve?": sometimes impulsive pursuit is driven by loneliness, boredom, or fear. Address the root, not just the symptom.
Health & Inner Work
- Interrupt automatic patterns: notice where your body moves without your mind's consent (snacking, scrolling, fidgeting). Insert a breath and a question: "Do I choose this?"
- Strengthen the pause: practice a 5-second gap between impulse and action. This is the space where agency lives.
- Examine attraction to intensity: do you chase stimulation (caffeine, drama, overtraining, conflict) to feel alive? Explore whether you can access aliveness through presence instead.
- Ground before deciding: when facing a choice, do a brief body scan or grounding exercise (feet on floor, breath in belly). Let the nervous system settle, then choose.
- Journal on "following": write about where you feel pulled by others' expectations, trends, or social pressure. What would change if you stopped following?
- Reclaim "no" as self-care: saying no to what does not serve you is not rejection—it is protection of your energy and integrity.
Finance & Strategy
- Beware FOMO trades: if you feel urgency to enter a position because "everyone is talking about it," that is influence in the thighs. Wait for your own thesis.
- Set entry rules: define objective criteria (technical setup, valuation range, risk/reward ratio) and do not act until they are met, regardless of market noise.
- Review impulsive purchases: track discretionary spending for two weeks. Highlight purchases made on impulse versus intention. Adjust habits accordingly.
- Delay gratification: practice the 30-day rule for non-essential purchases. If you still want it after 30 days, buy it. Most desires fade.
- Separate signal from hype: consume financial news and analysis critically. Ask who benefits from your action. Follow data, not narratives.
- Rebalance with intention: do not chase performance by rotating into last quarter's winners. Stick to your allocation strategy unless fundamentals have changed.
Timing, Signals, and Readiness
The third line often appears when you are on the verge of acting from attraction rather than alignment. The timing counsel is: wait until you can articulate why. If your reason is "I feel drawn to this" or "everyone else is doing it," you are still in the thighs. If your reason is "this serves X goal, aligns with Y value, and I have Z resources in place," you have moved into intentionality.
Watch for these signs that you are acting from impulse: urgency without clarity, excitement without a plan, movement without a destination, yes without consideration of cost. When these arise, pause. Ask: "What part of me is driving this—my thighs, my heart, or my mind?" Let the answer guide your next step.
Conversely, you are ready to move forward when: you have tested the attraction over time and it remains; you have consulted your values and strategy and found alignment; you can name both the benefits and the costs; and you feel calm resolve rather than anxious urgency. At that point, influence has risen from the thighs to the heart and mind, and action becomes wise.
When This Line Moves
A moving third line in Hexagram 31 signals a shift from impulsive reactivity toward grounded discernment. The transformation asks you to elevate the source of your influence—from automatic response to conscious choice. The resulting hexagram (determined by your divination method) will show the new configuration of forces once you have integrated this lesson.
Practical takeaway: if this line is moving, you are being called to reclaim agency. Identify one area where you have been "holding to following"—chasing trends, accommodating others, reacting to stimuli—and install a decision-making filter. This might be a waiting period, a set of criteria, a trusted advisor, or a reflective practice. The goal is to insert consciousness between attraction and action, so that your movement becomes yours again.
The movement from line three often brings relief. You stop scattering energy across every shiny object. You stop losing yourself in others' agendas. You begin to move with purpose, and that purpose restores dignity. The humiliation the oracle warns against is avoided not by suppressing desire, but by governing it with wisdom.
Concise Summary
Hexagram 31.3 warns against reflexive pursuit and compulsive following. Influence in the thighs is attraction without discernment, movement without intention. The oracle counsels restraint: pause between stimulus and response, test attractions against your values and strategy, and reclaim the power to choose. When you stop holding to following, you stop scattering yourself. Dignity is restored, energy is conserved, and your actions become expressions of will rather than reactions to impulse. Let attraction inform you, but let wisdom guide you.
Moving Line Dynamics
When the third line of Hexagram 31 changes, it typically transforms the hexagram into a new configuration that emphasizes structure, boundaries, or inner cultivation. The specific resulting hexagram depends on your casting method, but the thematic shift is consistent: from scattered responsiveness to centered intentionality.
In practice, this means the situation is asking you to stop being led by every attraction and to start leading from your core. The change may feel like a loss of spontaneity at first, but what you are actually losing is compulsion. What you gain is freedom—the freedom to choose, to prioritize, to say no, and to move only when movement serves your deeper purpose. This is not rigidity; it is sovereignty.